Review: The Trial and Tribulations of Miss Tilney

Plucky cub reporter Henrietta Tilney sits face to face with accused mass murderer Lord Beowulf Harwood. An interview she hoped would launch her writing career soon explodes into a whirlwind of deadly adventure, taking Tilney and the mysterious Harwood across Victorian London.

Writer: David Doub
Illustrator: Sarah Elkins (main story); Danielle Alexis St. Pierre (flashbacks)
Publisher: Dusk Comics

If there was one word that I would use to describe this book, it would be fun. Fun is a strange word, because it means different things to different people, but frankly I don’t think any of the other options rattling about in my head would work quite as well. I think that quirky and interesting would both work, but not nearly as well as fun.

How is it fun, you ask? And will it be fun for me? Honestly, I don’t know. I am working with my own bizarre use of the word, which means that there is something about the penny dreadful nature of the book that just appeals to me. I have kind of been a huge sucker for the pulpy, less-than-glamorous, but still wildly enjoyable area of the written word for some time now. The Trials and Tribulations of Miss Tilney was right up my alley, having a bit of bizarre mystery, a dash of the over-the-top and a smidgeon of steampunk. I’m not going to say that it is a book that everyone is going to love or even find the same enjoyment that I did, but if you’re willing to go out a little bit out of your comfort zone, then I definitely recommend it.

Give me a moment while I gush a little about the art. Art can make or break a good story and Sarah Elkin’s art is kind of beautiful. It’s visually stimulating without being a distraction, fitting the tone of the story rather than working in opposition to it. There’s a decidedly Victorian sort of bent to it, which goes along fabulously with the setting. The story itself picks up in the middle, with little back story or introduction for Miss Tilney, but it very quickly sets us going on the case that she is investigating. There were times where I was a little confused as to who was who and what was going on (I had to go back and reread), but I am going to say that it works for the story. We know who Miss Tilney is (intrepid reporter and keeper of an amazing nonplussed ‘nothing I haven’t seen before’ face while rocking a great hairstyle) and what she’s after, so she’s our window into the rest of the world. There is a bit of a novella-type flashback story at the end of the book, which was interesting but the cliffhanger in the main story left me itching for more. There’s a hint of steampunk without it ever being clarified if it is meant to be, which is fine. I would’ve preferred a little more clarity as to why Miss Tilney was so quick to side with the Lord and Doctor, but I’ll allow it. After all when it comes to penny dreadfuls, thinking too much about them is only bound to ruin the fun.

It’s something new and has something to it that I can’t quite put my finger on it, so I will definitely be checking out the next issue. I suggest that you definitely check it out, especially if you’re in the mood to give an indie comic a little love. It definitely won’t be boring.

The Trials and Tribulations of Miss Tilney is now for sale on both Amazon and B&N.com

About Lina

A university graduate with three too many degrees and an urge to just keep moving. Not too keen to stay on the beaten path, moving is all that she feels like doing. Pieced together from a little bit of everywhere (culturally speaking) she has a love of pop culture and learning that is kind of out of control. Sometimes she acts a little bit like an insane old British lady or an eight year old on speed. Let's not get her started on the books (or soap operas or her affection for making up drinking games). Then we'd be here all day.
This entry was posted in Misc, Review and tagged , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to Review: The Trial and Tribulations of Miss Tilney

  1. Doomedpaladin says:

    Where are you seeing steampunk? Its called a Victorian (or perhaps Edwardian) setting. Otherwise, thank you for your positive review.

    • Lina says:

      I’m going to apologize for any typos first and foremost, because I am on my phone, but perhaps I should have clarified a little more. It wasn’t blatant steampunk, per se, but more a hint of it in the character of the Doctor and his gadgety ways. It wasn’t bad nor was it distracting. I am fully willing to accept that it was something that I projected onto it.

      But no problem! It was a lot fun.

      • Doomedpaladin says:

        Cool. The Doctor is very much a beakers and syringes type, but that was all medical science in those time periods. We have the fourth member of our party, Brodrick (assuming David doesn’t change his name from the original RPG character), who is the manservant/mechanic of the group and he gets very gadget-ey later on. I’m happy you had fun reading it, it was a lot of fun to play, and I’m sure anyone who reads your blog here would enjoy it as much as you did. Thanks again for the great review.

  2. Pingback: Why Are There No Superstar Artists? Or, Comic News Sites Are Eating Their Own Tails By David Doub - Page 5

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

CommentLuv badge